Psychology has revealed that humans desire cognitive closure. We want definitive answers rather than endure the discomfort of ambiguity. We may make judgments prematurely rather than hold competing truths in tension. In Christianity, many things are black and white – and the world needs this clarity. Men are men and women are women. Life is life, no matter the stage. But when we are confronted with things that are slightly ambiguous, the temptation is to jump to a position without thoroughly weighing up the consequences of that position.
We need intellectual humility, and I am challenged by this daily. I have been especially challenged on this in my study of the Digital Duty of Care Bill. I have read and re-read the Bill, listened to the commentary, and I remain ever-mindful of potential threats to our freedoms. Whilst this Bill certainly presents certain threats, it is also the first Bill of its kind that takes seriously the responsibility to reduce the online proliferation of child sexual exploitation material, pornography, suicide and self-harm material, misogynistic material and eating disorder material. The government should be commended for its intention to remove this material from the internet.
The competing tensions are real, and in our analysis of this bill we hold them together.
Freedom
I am keenly aware that we have a government that interprets and positions legitimate subjects of debate as dangerous and a threat to democracy, whereas we believe debate must continue freely in the public square. We saw this threat to freedom clearly in the government’s attempt to pass its misinformation bill. The Digital Duty of Care Bill, though not as expansive in terms of its definitions, could still threaten freedom of public debate.
So far, we have identified two threats:
- The Minister is provided with authority to expand definitions or make biased determinations based on vague and subjective definitions.
a. Material that threatens ‘gender equality’ falls within the definition of serious harm to children. This may limit posts challenging gender ideology.
b. The Commissioner can determine ‘any other material or conduct, or combination of material and conduct, that may cause serious harm to children’. This is too vague and subjective.
- The Minister can order digital platforms to change design features that cause ‘negative behavioural impacts’. This could include scrolling, likes or sharing features. ‘Negative behavioural impacts’ is not defined. This could, again, lead to overreach.
Further to this, I have heard commentary and read articles alerting us to the danger of ‘sock puppet identities’. While we are yet to finalise our position on this, it could prove to be a legitimate way of catching child sexual exploitation predators.
Protection
In terms of the positive components of the Bill, digital platforms will be forced to remove seriously harmful material or conduct. The majority of the definitions are sound. The definitions are as follows:
(a) material or conduct that depicts, encourages, promotes, incites or instructs child sexual exploitation or child sexual abuse;
(b) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs grooming or procuring a child for sexual activity;
(c) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs sexual violence;
(d) fake nude material created without the consent of a person depicted;
(e) posting, or threatening to post, an intimate image of another person without the consent of the other person;
(f) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs extreme violence or cruelty;
(g) explicit threats of physical violence, including threats of rape and death threats;
(h) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs gender-based violence;
(i) material or conduct that is reasonably likely to cause serious harm by menacing or harassing an individual;
(j) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs individuals to:
(i) consider suicide or take their own life (otherwise than in the context of voluntary assisted dying); or
(ii) engage in self-harm; or
(iii) engage in sadistic online exploitation; or
(iv) cause harm to, or engage in cruelty against, animals;
(k) material or conduct that advocates for or supports a listed terrorist organisation (within the meaning of subsection 100.1(1) of the Criminal Code);
(l) material or conduct that counsels, promotes, encourages, urges or praises a terrorist act (within the meaning of subsection 100.1(1) of the Criminal Code);
(m) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs the commission of a serious Commonwealth offence that is reasonably likely to cause serious harm;
(n) violent extremist material (within the meaning of the Criminal Code);
(o) material or conduct that encourages, promotes, incites or instructs abhorrent violent conduct.
And then material that is harmful to children includes:
(a) pornography;
(b) material or conduct that encourages, promotes or instructs disordered eating;
(c) material or conduct that encourages or promotes hostile attitudes towards women or gender equality;
(d) material or conduct that glorifies crime or encourages dangerous stunts or seriously harmful practices;
(e) abuse, harassment or bullying;
(f) any other material or conduct, or combination of material and conduct, that may cause serious harm to children.
I hope you would agree that most of these should be commended, although ‘gender equality‘ is highly problematic, as is the final ambiguous clause allowing for ‘any other material’ to be removed.
The allowance for voluntary assisted dying (VAD) to be discussed online is also problematic. This actually proves our ongoing stance that VAD is in fact ‘suicide’, but because it is now legal everywhere in Australia, discussing it online is permitted by this Bill.
Finally, as I mentioned in my introduction, I propose we adopt a posture of intellectual humility and hold both freedom and legitimate protection in tension. This Bill is a significant attempt by the government to regulate a highly complex space. It will never be perfect, but care must be taken to protect freedom of expression and debate. However, freedom of expression and debate should not be held at the expense of our care for the vulnerable.
This is where the necessary tension exists. May we pray that the government applies wisdom to this balance. And may we especially be praying for the millions of children who are exploited online.







